Volker Schlöndorff transposes Bertolt Brecht’s late-expressionist work to latter-day 1969. Poet and anarchist Baal lives in an attic and reads his poems to cab drivers. At first feted and later rejected by bourgeois society, Baal roams through forests and along motorways, greedy for schnapps, cigarettes, women and men: ‘You have to let out the beast, let him out into the sunlight.’ After impregnating a young actress he soon comes to regard her as a millstone round his neck. He stabs a friend to death and dies alone. ‘You are useless, mangy and wild, you beast, you crawl through the lowest boughs of the tree.’
The film takes youthful impetuousness and hatred of oppression as its subject and also ponders the cult of genius and sexual morals. Rainer Werner Fassbinder simultaneously plays both Baal and himself and is surrounded by many actors who were later to perform in his own films. After the film was broadcast on West German television, Brecht’s widow Helene Weigel prohibited any further screenings, arguing that the social circumstances engendering Baal’s rebelliousness had not been adequately explained.
"broken people save broken people"，“同是天涯沦落人”。
这根本不是珠玉在前的问题，而是这个改编完全就是零蛋水平的问题。
a one-man show. short but brief.
6.5/10.暴躁的911接线员，救人的过程其实也是自我救赎的过程。剧情反转之前比较沉闷，反转过后也没好多少。好莱坞在疫情期间拍了不少这种独角戏或者只有两个角色的电影，这也是一种自救。
打电话求救的妈妈……太好莱坞式疯子女人，同时是妈妈，并且疯了，非常讨厌这一类角色刻画，因为妈妈实际上很少发疯。
聲音演戲，認真好片。"broken people saved broken people." 孰能無過。劇中一個小反轉就足以讓我震驚得汗毛直豎。
Emmm……behind the scene
【B】观感挺不错，杰克吉伦哈尔的演技进步太多了。音效制作和节奏都把控得很棒，特别是音效代入感很强，全片都在调动观众情绪。
看过原版就觉得好像也就那样了（变成全程看Jake肱二头肌）（不是）🙊
喜欢这种就靠剧情取胜的小成本制作，罪人的自我救赎，各种电话里的演员演技就要秒杀国内众多了，有点诧异评分太低，搜了一下果然是翻拍，不过没看过原版，所以没有很挑剔，自己喜欢就行了
原版本就没太好 这版翻拍更为平庸 好莱坞式的结局太烂了 也就吉伦哈尔的演技值得一看
观影时，你需要熬过前面的剧情铺垫部分。
杰克吉伦哈尔的演技可圈可点 但是剧本台词比起其他单人独幕剧来说太太太单薄了 紧急惊悚啥的完全看不到吧 困死我了
电影是吉伦哈尔一个人的独角戏，演技也没得挑剔，但是电影整体来说显得平庸，可参考哈利贝瑞的危情911
小空间依靠电话推进影片情节，不容易拍好，即使杰克卖力的表演。。。
即便是翻拍这个分数也真的太低了，是福奎阿的镜头不好还是吉伦哈尔的表演不强？！这种怼脸的大特写对导演和演员的要求都太高了，而且人物的心理轨迹要比原版还要清晰完整，这么局促的空间内节奏好得不得了，每一个气口都位置都对，且该短短该长长的（除了结尾厕所戏结尾长的有点狗尾续貂），豆瓣这评分是不是有点装大了？！
密闭空间失败品典型之一，在调度和剧本苍白的情况下，出色的演员很难挽回影片的水准。
7分。丹麦版本的翻拍，没啥新意。一些细节上的修正也没什么特别的。不过Jake Gyllenhaal的表演还是很不错的，基本上，也就是靠他的表演撑起这部小成本片了~~~
不及原版，杰克吉伦哈尔全程表演过火，输出靠吼。
食之无味弃之可惜，或许把很多场面给铺开会好很多，画面真的太单调了。
Copyright © 2015-2023 All Rights Reserved
